hroughout baseball history, pitchers and hitters have
adjusted daily to the strike zone idiosyncrasies of the home plate
umpire. Now umpires are adjusting, too, depending on the site of the
game, and they say their adjustments can influence the outcome of
games.
The reason, four umpires said yesterday, is the QuesTec system
that Major League Baseball uses to monitor umpires' calls of balls
and strikes and to rate the umpires on the accuracy of their calls.
The system is used in at least nine parks, including both in New
York, and is expected to be in 13 parks as the season progresses.
But, the umpires said, the strike zone created by the system varies
from park to park, forcing them to alter their strike zones from
park to park. The umpires say they can have yet another strike zone
in the parks where they are not monitored.
"It's having an effect on the game," said one umpire, who like
all of the umpires who commented in telephone interviews did so only
if they would not be identified.
"It's definitely a concern," another umpire said.
Umpires have questioned the QuesTec system for the past year, but
the commissioner's office has forced them to try to comply with the
QuesTec strike zone. Umpires have been told that if at least 90
percent of their calls do not conform with QuesTec calls, they are
guilty of below-standard umpiring.
"I try to call the game I would normally call," one umpire said,
"but I think about QuesTec every once in a while. When you start
thinking, you're in trouble. The worst feeling an umpire can have is
second-guessing yourself. That's what QuesTec does. Umpires say they
are losing their confidence."
Another umpire said he and his colleagues had to change their
strike zones from QuesTec park to QuesTec park. "For years, you're
reacting to what happens; you call what you see,'' he said. "In a
QuesTec city, you say, 'What is the machine going to say?' not 'What
was that pitch?' Pretty soon you're umpiring a video game, not a
baseball game. It affects your mind-set of what you're doing out on
the field."
What makes the system worse, this umpire said, is that the strike
zone, which is established by the computer operator, varies from
park to park, from at-bat to at-bat with the same batter and
sometimes even from pitch to pitch.
Sandy Alderson, executive vice president for baseball operations
under Commissioner Bud Selig, did not return a telephone call
yesterday seeking comment, but on Tuesday he strongly defended the
system, telling The Associated Press that "the umpires have never
been more accurate and more consistent about the strike zone and the
rule book than they are today."
The QuesTec system, which the World Umpires Association has
challenged in a grievance that is scheduled to be heard in July, has
come under public scrutiny since last Saturday night, when e Arizona
pitcher Curt Schilling took a bat to one of the cameras through
which the system operates at the Diamondbacks' Bank One Ballpark. His earned run average this season is
4.39 in six starts at home and 1.96 in three starts on the road.
Schilling will most likely be disciplined for his action, but he
gained the gratitude of umpires and fellow pitchers who have come to
believe that the system has affected umpires' pitch calls.
"We hear it all the time," Al Leiter of the Mets said in
Philadelphia before the Mets' game there last night. "There are a
number of umpires saying: 'Al, I'm on the computer tonight. It's a
computer night.' "
Tom Glavine, also a Mets pitcher, said he had heard similar
comments from umpires. Several umpires spoke of being forced to call
a narrower strike zone in QuesTec parks.
"I think that's unfair that they're under pressure to call a
different game," Glavine said. "To me, either everybody has it or
nobody has it. Whether or not it does anything, if there's even the
slightest potential that because of it being somewhere, the game's
going to be different versus it not being there, that's tough."
Alderson said the system was easy to operate, but the umpires
interviewed yesterday disagreed. They said the system's accuracy
varied from operator to operator and depended on the way the
operators calibrated the system and the way they set the strike zone
from a snapshot taken as the first pitch to a batter was on the way
to the plate.
Because of the variations, one umpire said, umpires do not know
what the dimensions of the strike zone were until 30 minutes after
the game.
"It's an exercise in frustration," he said, adding: "You spend
your whole career trying to get good enough to be on the major
league level and some guy comes along 30 minutes after the game and
tells you based on a grainy photograph where the strike zone
was."
Because of the differences they say exist, the umpires said, they
share information about the different parks where QuesTec is
used.
"It's human nature," one umpire said. "If a truck driver is going
down the road and sees a cop, he lets everyone know there's a cop.
You go to a QuesTec city and you pass on information about it."
Another umpire said, "We also share the despair going from park
to park."