SLAMABAD, Pakistan, Nov. 21 ?In a reception room at a
Taliban ministry of defense building in Kabul, a brightly colored
map depicting the American military presence in the Arabian
peninsula was painted on a wall. An identical map appears in a book
written by Osama bin Laden declaring a holy war on the United
States.
Although it has long been known that Mr. bin Laden had great
influence over the Taliban, the full extent of the ties may become
clearer as more documents are seized and more insiders come
forward.
The picture ?still far from complete ?is of a relationship
nourished by Mr. bin Laden's access to vast wealth, ties that
ultimately led an essentially Afghan religious movement into a more
global jihad and, eventually, doom.
One of the primary reasons Mr. bin Laden exerted so much
influence over Afghanistan was clearly his relationship with Mullah
Muhammad Omar, the one-time clerk who rose to become spiritual
leader of the Taliban, which sealed control over most of Afghanistan
after taking over Kabul in 1996.
Insiders say Mullah Omar and Mr. bin Laden spent many hours in
deep discussion of the intricacies of Islam, often by the light of
kerosene lamps in the hideouts both men resorted to as the world's
pressures against them mounted. Mr. bin Laden played to the mullah's
vanity by declaring him caliph, a title reserved through the
1,400-year history of Islam for the leader of the faithful.
In turn, the Taliban leader turned his back on most of the rest
of the world to support his patron.
Interviews with intelligence officials in Pakistan and Kabul, and
conversations with knowledgeable residents in the Afghan capital
present a picture of a growing closeness between the two men.
Sometime in the last year, Mr. bin Laden swore "bayat," an
Islamic oath of fealty, to Mullah Omar. By January of this year, at
the wedding of one of his sons, the terrorist leader began to call
Mullah Omar the caliph.
In return, the Taliban leader provided a base and protection for
Al Qaeda, Mr. bin Laden's organization, and assented as Mr. bin
Laden sent out videotapes calling on Muslims worldwide to commit
their sons and their money to the terrorist camps he established in
the remote deserts and mountains of Afghanistan.
This closeness raises many questions that, for now, have not been
adequately answered. Why, for instance, did Saudi Arabia continue to
recognize and support the Taliban government until after the Sept.
11 attacks even as the country proclaimed Mr. bin Laden to be an
enemy?
When the State Department announced tens of millions of dollars
in drought relief for a Taliban-led Afghanistan earlier this year,
how aware was it of Mr. bin Laden's influence over the
government?
The terrorists who went to Afghanistan were more resolute in
their sense of Islam than the Afghan militants, according to a
Western intelligence official who spent time in the country during
the 1990's.
"The Afghans were in awe and fear of the Arabs who had this much
deeper commitment," the official said.
Not all of the Arabs, Pakistanis and others who went to
Afghanistan to fight were members of Al Qaeda, but those who were
received special treatment as the royalty of terrorism.
Residents of Kabul complained this week that they lived under a
virtual occupation by Arabs and Pakistanis during the Taliban's
rule. They described thousands of Pakistanis and Arabs roaming the
streets of the city as an elite that enforced its own strict moral
and religious code on the population.
Poverty-stricken Afghans watched in envy as the government gave
foreigners the biggest homes in upper- class neighborhoods. The
Arabs drove new Japanese-made pickup trucks and ate out at
restaurants nightly.
Muhammad Sadiq, a shopkeeper in the Wasir Akbar Khan section of
Kabul, the wealthy former diplomatic quarter where Al Qaeda members
occupied several houses, said Arabs and other foreign volunteers in
the area were good customers. But he added: "In my heart I was angry
at them. They were invaders."
As the power of Mr. bin Laden and his network grew, so did the
rumors. Commanders of the rebel Northern Alliance said Mullah Omar
had turned into a puppet of the terrorist leader. One tool used by
alliance commanders to motivate their troops in recent weeks has
been the argument that their country had been taken over by
foreigners.
Prince Turki bin Faisal, who recently stepped down as chief of
intelligence for Saudi Arabia, said he saw the change in Mullah Omar
over the course of a few months in 1998, when he twice visited
Kandahar, the mullah's southern stronghold, to try to persuade the
Taliban to extradite Mr. bin Laden to Saudi Arabia for trial on
charges of advocating the overthrow of the royal family.
In June of that year, Mullah Omar promised to give Mr. bin Laden
to the Saudis. By the time the intelligence chief returned in
September, the Taliban leader had reversed his decision. He had also
adopted Mr. bin Laden's position on many issues, including Saudi
Arabia.
"Mullah Omar started using harsh language against the kingdom,"
the prince said in an interview today. "He used the same words that
bin Laden uses, about the presence of infidel troops despoiling the
land of the two holy mosques and people have a right to declare a
jihad to liberate the holy land from these infidel operators."
Along with the personal bond between the two men, there was the
Taliban's deepening financial dependence on Mr. bin Laden, whose
fortune may have run dry in the 1990's but who remained a conduit
for millions of dollars donated to his cause through charities and
front organizations by wealthy Saudis and other Arabs.
Some contributors apparently believed in the vision of holy war
or favored terrorist strikes on America; some other powerful figures
in Saudi Arabia and other Arab countries seemed to be buying
protection against the possibility that Mr. bin Laden's version of
Islamic militancy might one day sweep away the Persian Gulf
monarchies.
The money built hospitals and training camps for terrorists, and,
intelligence officials said, bought weapons for the Taliban and the
Arabs and other Muslims who flocked to Afghanistan.
The rising influence of the outsiders caused tensions in the
Taliban, with some elements ?including the foreign minister and
health minister, a Pakistani government official said ?expressing
resentment. But no one was able to dislodge Mr. bin Laden.
"It was not a seamless relationship, but the Taliban became
dependent on bin Laden and Al Qaeda resources, and the outsiders
exerted more and more influence over the government," a Western
diplomat in the region said.
A Pakistani official blamed Mr. bin Laden and his associates for
persuading the Taliban to destroy the giant statues of Buddha in
Bamyan Province, which were among the most revered monuments in the
Buddhist world.
He also said the hard-line foreigners had persuaded the Taliban
to harass United Nations workers into fleeing the country and to
prosecute eight Christian aid workers.
Well before Mr. bin Laden's arrival in 1996, the Taliban had
taken steps to isolate their country and return to strict
interpretations of the Koran. In addition, many Taliban leaders and
fighters had fought alongside foreign Muslims who helped them drive
out Soviet troops in the 1980's.
The Taliban's brand of radical Islam was rooted in the code and
culture of Afghan village life. Mullah Omar and his compatriots did
not show the slightest concern about the outside world until Mr. bin
Laden appeared on the scene.
Under the tutelage of his guest, Mullah Omar began to see his
goal as more than the liberation of Afghanistan and he progressively
signed on to the idea of a worldwide jihad against the United
States.
Still, differences remained. "There was a closeness, but I would
not go as far as saying bin Laden was the de facto defense
minister," a Western diplomat said. "The Taliban and Al Qaeda were
not one and the same."
Some of the evidence left behind in the Defense Ministry house
indicated the gap between Mr. bin Laden, the guest under fire, and
Mullah Omar, the beleaguered protector.
In an exchange of letters full of theological reasoning, Mr. bin
Laden asked Mullah Omar not to turn him over to the Americans, and
the Taliban leader granted his request.
But items left in the ministry building and houses occupied by Al
Qaeda members showed that the Taliban government aided the terrorist
network's operations inside Afghanistan.
Documents showed that Al Qaeda was closely integrated with the
Taliban Ministry of Defense in the field. For instance, maps of
front-line Taliban positions across the country were found in Al
Qaeda houses, and neighbors said the men who lived in the houses
regularly traveled to the front lines.
While some of Al Qaeda's men may be trapped in the northwestern
Afghan city of Kunduz, most seem to have vanished along with their
leader.
What is clear is that Mullah Omar and Mr. bin Laden are separated
and have no way of communicating.
Tayab Agha, the mullah's secretary, told reporters in the Afghan
city of Spin Boldak today that the Taliban did not know where Mr.
bin Laden was and that what was left of the government no longer had
a relationship with the man who brought the might of the United
States and its allies down on Afghanistan.