IENNA, Nov. 10 ?In the last year, there have been dozens
of violations of nuclear security rules in Russia and at least one
loss of fissile material; Taliban emissaries have tried to recruit
Russian scientists, and terrorists have tried to stake out a Russian
nuclear storage site at least twice, say senior officials of the
International Atomic Energy Agency and Western governments.
The officials detailed the incidents, citing conversations with
Russian officials and verified news reports. Despite significant
improvements in Russian nuclear security in the 1990's ?some of it
with American money and advice ?up to half of ex-Soviet civilian and
military nuclear stockpiles with weapons-grade material are not well
protected.
Officials of the Vienna-based International Atomic Energy Agency,
the United Nations body for monitoring nuclear programs, are deeply
skeptical of Osama bin Laden's claim, in an interview published in
Pakistan on Friday, that he possesses nuclear weapons.
On the other hand, given the vulnerability of material in the
former Soviet Union, the increasing professionalism of nuclear
smuggling and the relative ease of fabricating a primitive weapon,
they cannot rule it out.
In the Kazakh port of Aktau on the Caspian shore, one ton of
plutonium and two tons of highly enriched uranium sit near a now
closed breeder reactor.
Ukraine, with 17 nuclear reactors and one research reactor, is
considered a country of "serious concern" by officials because of
its climate of government corruption and crime. Enough highly
enriched uranium to make a bomb remains at a research reactor just
outside Belgrade throughout the 1999 Kosovo war.
Just last week, Turkey announced it had broken up a gang of
smugglers who tried to sell 2.2 pounds of what appeared to be highly
enriched uranium for $750,000 to undercover police officers,
material they said they had bought several months ago from a Russian
of Azeri origin.
Officials are increasingly concerned that terrorists willing to
die could create a "dirty bomb," wrapping more easily stolen
radioactive materials used in medicine and industry around a
conventional explosive, like dynamite, to try to make a significant
area of a city uninhabitable for many years.
Russian officials say their fissile nuclear material is under
strict and improving controls. But only 10 days ago, in a discussion
with officials at the United Nations agency here, Yuri G. Volodin,
chief of safeguards for the Russian nuclear regulatory agency,
revealed that in the last year, there were dozens of violations of
Russia's regulations for securing and accounting for nuclear
material.
Mr. Volodin noted one loss of nuclear material, which he called
of the "highest consequence." He said he could not be more specific
about the type of material or the size of the loss.
Last month, Col.-Gen. Igor Volynkin, head of nuclear security for
Russia's military, said that twice this year Russian forces
discovered stakeouts by terrorists of a secret nuclear arms storage
facility, although he did not say where.
Also last month, an official of the Russian Security Council,
Raisa Vdovichenko, told Russian journalists that emissaries of the
Taliban had asked an employee of "an institution related to nuclear
technologies to go to their country to work there in this
field."
There is continuing evidence of efforts to traffic in nuclear
material that give many officials deep concern.
In April 2000, the police in Georgia seized, in Batumi, several
hundred fast-reactor fuel pellets, containing 920 grams ?nearly a
kilogram ?of highly enriched uranium; in September, at Tbilisi
airport, the police confiscated half a gram of plutonium.
The Russians say they thwarted an effort, at the very end of
1998, by an organized gang to steal 18.5 kilograms ?more than 40
pounds ?of highly enriched uranium from a military weapons facility
near Chelyabinsk in the Urals.
Still, senior officials here and in Washington do not believe
that Mr. bin Laden or even any state interested in a shortcut to a
bomb ?from Syria and Iran to Iraq and Libya ?has been able to obtain
the roughly 25 kilograms (55 pounds) of highly enriched uranium
required to make a simple bomb, or the roughly 8 kilograms (17.6
pounds) of plutonium, a much more difficult material with which to
work.
But they also admit that they cannot possibly know for sure.
The atomic energy agency has built a database of incidents of
nuclear trafficking since 1993 ?only counting incidents confirmed by
the states involved. Of the 175 cases of trafficking in nuclear
material and 201 cases of trafficking in medical and industrial
radioactive materials, only some 18 cases involved even small
amounts of the fissionable material needed for a nuclear bomb
?plutonium or highly enriched uranium (enriched by 20 percent or
more).
Altogether in all these cases, agency officials say, there have
been seizures of about 400 grams (nearly one pound) of plutonium and
an additional 12 kilograms (26.4 pounds) of uranium at varying
levels of enrichment, equivalent to only some 6 kilograms of uranium
235.
The most serious cases, involving large amounts of material, took
place in 1993 and 1994, when Russian, German and Czech police
officers made large seizures of very highly enriched nuclear
material manufactured in the former Soviet Union, usually at
nuclear-fuel fabrication plants.
In March 1993, in St. Petersburg, nearly three kilograms (6.6
pounds) of 90 percent enriched uranium-238 were seized; in August
1994, in Munich, the police seized about 360 grams of Russian-made
plutonium; in December 1994, 2.7 kilograms (just over 5 pounds) of
80 percent enriched uranium-235 were seized, part of a shipment that
showed up in smaller amounts in other places ?and which officials
hope was not part of an even larger shipment, apparently stolen from
the Russian nuclear research center in Obninsk, about an hour's
drive southwest of Moscow.
For context, officials point out, Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein had
made only 1.5 kilograms (3.3 pounds) of bomb-capable uranium before
the gulf war broke out.
But in fact the atomic energy agency's database is only a guide,
and perhaps not even a good one. "Are we seeing half the iceberg or
only the tip?" said one official, noting that the police consider
seizures of drugs, a commodity far easier to secure, to represent
only some 10 to 20 percent of what is shipped. Nor does the agency,
devoted to civilian nuclear energy, know much about the military
programs of states with nuclear weapons.
Friedrich Steinh?sler, a physics professor at Stanford University
and co-director of a Stanford center on the physical protection of
nuclear materials, said, "It's clear that we're seeing a typical
move toward professionalism in this smuggling business, with
increasingly fewer incidents of significance, but of greater
significance, as professionals are probing the market."
He noted that traffickers increasingly are going south, over
traditional smuggling routes through Turkey, the Caucasus and
especially central Asia, closer to Afghanistan, where borders are
extremely long and lax.
Matthew Bunn, assistant director of the science, technology and
public policy program at Harvard University's Kennedy School, was a
Clinton White House adviser. The main source of loose nuclear
material remains the former Soviet Union, he says, with some 600
tons of weapons- grade nuclear material stored there outside of
warheads.
The key question, he says, is to improve the security around
military and especially civilian nuclear installations. In as many
as half, he said, there are no automatic detectors that sound an
alarm if material is smuggled out, and no security cameras where
material is stored.
"For all the work we've done with Russia, after seven years, we
still have most of the job to do," Mr. Bunn said. "This is a serious
threat, and we know how to fix it," he said, urging that President
Bush agree with Russia at the this week's summit meeting to account
for and secure all nuclear material.
Some safeguards put in place by the Americans in the former
Soviet Union no longer function, agency officials said ?spare parts
are expensive and available only from the United States, and
sometimes guards do not bother to use the equipment.
The Vienna agency is also looking for a 10 percent increase in
its own budget of some $320 million, said Graham Andrew, the special
assistant for Scientific and Technical Affairs, to upgrade security
standards around the world. He and other officials regard a
terrorist nuclear bomb to be "highly unlikely."
But the likelihood of terrorists compiling the radioactive
materials necessary to make a dirty bomb with immense economic and
psychological impact is much higher, the officials say.
The dirty bomb is an almost ideal instrument of terror, Mr. Bunn
said. It would not kill many people, but it would terrify, and make
a large area unsafe to work or live in, possibly for decades or
longer.
One official said: "Imagine a dirty bomb on the Washington mall.
Do you abandon the White House?"