ASHINGTON, Nov. 24 — An expert panel that
includes some of the government's leading emergency managers
has recommended the creation of a high-technology national
warning system that would alert the public to emergencies,
including terrorist attacks and other crises.
In a report scheduled to be made public on Monday, the
group said that the government's current emergency warning
systems were inefficient and outdated, and that a new
integrated system should be the responsibility of the
Department of Homeland Security.
While the group did not call for the end of the color-coded
terrorism alert system created in March by the White House, it
did note that there was widespread public confusion over the
system.
The group, which calls itself the Partnership for Public
Warning and includes representatives from the Federal
Emergency Management Agency, the Federal Bureau of
Investigation, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the
American Red Cross, said the current hodgepodge of emergency
warning systems "do not reach most of the people at risk."
"We believe that the new Department of Homeland Security
should take responsibility for leading development of a
national all-hazard public warning architecture," the group
said. "The need for such a system is considered extremely
compelling."
President Bush is scheduled on Monday to sign the bill
creating the Department of Homeland Security and to announce
that he will nominate Tom Ridge, now the White House domestic
security adviser, to be the department's first secretary. The
department would formally open its doors in late January.
A spokesman for Mr. Ridge, Gordon Johndroe, said today that
the administration was already studying the nation's emergency
warning systems.
"Since Sept. 11, we've been looking at the most effective
ways to alert people to the terrorism threat," Mr. Johndroe
said. "We are in the process of working with a variety of
industries, their associations, as well as media organizations
and government entities."
The group's report, which grew out of a conference among
the emergency managers last June, noted that the federal
warning system known as the Emergency Alert System was a
vestige of the cold war and had been "designed to allow the
president to warn the entire nation of major events such as an
incoming enemy missile with a nuclear warhead."
The group suggested that a new system could allow the
government to issue warnings of terrorist attacks and other
threats via telephone, cellphone, television and radio,
possibly through computer chips embedded in the devices.
"Warnings about events seconds, minutes or hours away need
to be disseminated rapidly through special warning systems,"
the group said. "At 2 a.m., traditional communications
channels are simply ineffective."
The chairman of the panel, Peter Ward, a retired
seismologist with the United States Geological Survey, said in
an interview that much of the technology needed to create a
national alert system already existed. "We're not talking
about big money; we're not talking about big government," Mr.
Ward said.
He said the need for the system had grown immensely since
the Sept. 11 attacks and that the government needed to find a
way on a neighborhood-by-neighborhood, even person-by-person,
basis to alert the public to imminent threats.
"Our vision down the road is that every person at risk from
natural disaster, an accident or terrorism would get a
heads-up," he said. "Every piece of electronics you own — be
it a cellphone, a car phone, a computer, a radio, a television
— should have the ability of giving you that heads-up."
He said the possibility that terrorists might use weapons
of mass destruction on American soil should increase the
urgency to create a technically advanced system.
"It's not hard to think of many scenarios with weapons of
mass destruction where, if you can get to people right away
and tell them to get out of harm's way, you can save thousands
of lives," he said. "Our ability to do that at the moment is
almost nonexistent. What worries me is that one of these days,
an event like that will happen and thousands of people will
die, and they didn't need to."